A comparative welfare regime approach to global social policy. This extensively revised edition of a handbook of comparative social policy provides uptodate and valuable insights on key concepts and issues, such as globalization, crime, diversity, housing, child poverty, gender inequality, and social policy regimes. This article aims to provide a succinct historical overview of comparative social policy. Although we seek to be comprehensive in the topics we cover, we do not claim to be exhaustive in our citations. Msc in comparative social policy university of oxford. College of education school of continuing and distance education 20142015 20162017 soci 222 comparative social institutions session 1 nature and functions of social. Theories and methods in comparative social policy deborah. This essay will discuss the methodological problems of selecting cases in medium. Comparative research seeks to compare and contrast nations, cultures, societies, and institutions. Policy transfer and the internationalisation of social policy rob hulme department of applied community studies, manchester metropolitan university email.
Hollowing out the nationstate and multilevel governance chapter 2. The generation of theory or theorytesting is another branch of comparative social policy, which is responsible for some of the most classic works in comparative social policy analysis, as. Jun 28, 20 the current context of social policy is one in which many of the old certainties of the past have been eroded. Computerassisted text analysis for comparative politics. Comparative social policies and comparative social security. Comparative institutional analysis commonly employs typologies to map.
Many of the issues surrounding the theories and methods in comparative work are not exclusive to crossnational studies, or to social policy. Social policy in comparative and historical perspective usage in comparative and historical studies. In the analysis of data collected in comparative study, it is a common practice for practioners to adopt costbenefit analysis in data analysis but the limitation of this. Policy research is a process of analysing a fundamental social problem in order to provide policy makers with recommendations to alleviate the problem. Defining comparative social policy request pdf researchgate.
About the coursethe msc in comparative social policy explores welfare systems and policy developments across a range of countries with an oecd focus. To circumvent a long history of debate on this subject, we begin with an account of social policy in the west as the product of a dual movement. Durso, colts neck, is a senior at the university of pennsylvania where he will receive a b. The predominantly inwardlooking, domestic preoccupation of social policy has made way for a more integrated, international and outward approach to analysis which looks beyond the boundaries of the state.
New developments in the theory of comparative social policy. Wong hung associate professor department of social work 9. List of issues journal of international and comparative. Comparative public policy introduction public policy is the study of what governments do, and do not do. Comparative public policy portland state university. Typified by both challenges and benefits, comparative social policy started to experience a period of growth in the 1960s, a time characterized by the dominance of the socalled keynesian welfare. The comparative politics of immigration princeton university.
Theories and methods in comparative social policy birkbeck. The advantages and disadvantages of different social. Pdf a handbook of comparative social policy falikh. This file can also be edited the way you want it to be shaped. Journal of international and comparative social policy. Each component of the problem analysis corresponds to a policy piece. Dancygier, immigration and con ict in europe,newyork,cambridge university press, 2010. We conclude that scholars would do well not to treat american social policy as so exceptional as to require separate. It suggests that crossnational research must go beyond its traditional boundaries of the nation state and the bureaucratic system of statebased provision. The advantages and disadvantages of different social welfare strategies by lawrence h. The comparative element is a key part of the course, and is one feature that makes the course at oxford unique. Comparative social policy is concerned with social policy research in more than one country. Marc morje howard, the politics of citizenship in europe,newyork,cambridge university press, 2009. This introductory essay identifies the issues that define comparative policy analysis, suggests reasons for its relative neglect, and argues for its inclusion in the general field of policy analysis.
Typified by both challenges and benefits, comparative social policy started to experience a period of growth in the 1960s, a time characterized by the dominance of the socalled keynesian welfare state. Such kind of research begins with a social problem which in this case is the shortage of housing among lowincome earners. Social policies to address social problems although social policies are designed to address problems, sometimes they create social problems. Comparative social policy provides students with an introduction to crossnational social policy research, conveying the fascinating and challenging issues involved in conducting research of this kind. The analytical framework provides a common structure for summarizing the advantages and limitations of the proposed policies, with. Soci 222 comparative social institutions session social change and social institutions lecturer. Comparative public policy has become an important field of study within the policy sciences more in. Ppt introduction to social policy powerpoint presentation. Youll start with a solid introduction to comparative social research methods and social policy analysis. Comparative research is a method of analyzing and comparing different populations and how they differ from each other.
In order to clarify this point of view, we shall first discuss some of the existing. If social policy is the public pursuit of secure welfare, we must first dwell upon the meaning of public action. In comparative social policy it is an inherent perspective. Thompson the following was delivered by the author to the high level american meeting of experts on the challenges of social reform and new adminis trative and financial management techniques. The aim of this course is to introduce students to the field of social policy. Understanding theories and concepts in social policy bristol. A handbook of comparative social policy, second edition. The book examines the theoretical, conceptual and methodological approaches, discusses prevailing concepts and reflects on methodological difficulties. A broader, comparative typology of regimes welfare state, informal security, insecurity is proposed, which captures the essential relationships between social and cultural conditions, institutional performance, welfare outcomes and path dependence. The qualitative comparative analysis focuses on the detailed study of all the topics that are compared with the base one. Pdf this article aims to provide a succinct historical overview of comparative social policy. Social policy in the modern world a comparative text pdf social policy in the modern world. Introduction to social policy is the property of its rightful owner.
More specifically, it is the investigation of what policies are and how they perform policy analysis as well as how they come into being and are implemented policy process. Journal of comparative social welfare 2006 2012 new global development 1995 2005 journal of international and comparative social welfare 1984 1994. Social policy, taken to mean societal responses to social risks poverty, inequality, crime, violence, age, and disability is among the most assailed policy areas throughout the world. The intention is to see and to explore the utility of comparative method for policy studies and policy analysis, since a new approach evidencebased policymaking arise, emphasising the importance of using evidence from other political and policy systems.
Us social policy in comparative and historical perspective ars 2001. View comparative social policy research papers on academia. Each institution is made up of a network of statuses and roles such as husband, wife etc. Handbook of research methods in public administration, second edition,edited by.
Introduction in the west and some other advanced capitalist countries, many of the security needs of individuals have come to be provided through formal welfare states, embracing a combination. Education policy research series discussion document no. A handbook of comparative social policy, second edition edited by patricia kennett, professor, school for policy studies, university of bristol, uk the current context of social policy is one in which many of the old certainties of the past have been eroded. Or you can check our files on research analysis to have more. For example, while access to a wide and more varied. As will be seen below, comparative social policy has not only grown enormously over the past. Hopefully it will stimulate the development of a social policy teaching pro. Handbook of comparative public budgeting and financial management, edited by thomas d. The actual subject matter of the course falls into three broad categories. Online resourcessearching workshop for msc comparative. Comparative social policy examines a number of key issues, debates and policy responses to social issues affecting the uk today, but viewed within in an international, comparative context.
The contributions of all authors to the book and this summary are gratefully acknowledged. Handbook of global social policy, edited by stuart s. International institute of social studies, erasmus university rotterdam yearterm. The research method skills are assessed by means of formal course assignments and methods essays on published research papers.
The book will introduce students to essential concepts relating to welfare provision as well as providing an indepth analysis of those policy areas most commonly associated with welfare programmes worldwide, including health, social care, housing, employment, education and environmental policy. The report produced should observe standards and requirements of academic writing and style. Course information sheet for entry in 201617 msc in. Comparative social policy schar school george mason university.
The book examines the theoretical, conceptual and methodological approaches, discusses prevailing concepts and reflects on methodological. Introduce and explore some key macro comparative data sources and software packages. These challenges include changing demographic trends and economic conditions which have been accompanied by the emergence of new needs and risks within and across societies. The course provides an overview of the main theories and empirical developments in welfare state and social policy analysis. Survey methodology aims to measure general patterns among a population through statistical methods. One will cover comparative social policy welfare states in general. Research methodology applied to a comparative case study. Geof wood and ian gough a comparative welfare regime. As an observational method, a comparative analysis examines the variables in a given period to gain substantial results. Social policy in the modern world a comparative text pdf. Nielsen department of political science, massachusetts institute of technology, 77. In the past decade, active labour market policy almp has become a major topic in comparative social policy analysis, with scholars exploiting crossnational variation to seek to identify the determinants of policy development in this central area of the new welfare state. Journal of international and comparative social policy 20 2019 formerly known as.
Comparative social policies and comparative social security prof. It is in this context that this handbook brings together the work of key commentators in the field of comparative analysis in order to provide comprehensive coverage of contemporary debates and issues in crossnational social policy research. The ma in comparative and international social policy is based around a combination of social policy analysis and research training. Distinction between economic and social policy is based on the assumption that free play of economic forces creates diswelfares which social policies then need. May 02, 2010 a comparative analysis of the social media policies of dell, ibm, rightnow technologies and ball state university. Types of comparative research 2 institutions doing comparative research and areas of focus 3 comparative papers 4 comparative rural policy papers 6 comparative studies journals 7 references 8. If so, share your ppt presentation slides online with. Youll then explore how social policy is affected by globalisation.
Geof wood and ian gough a comparative welfare regime approach. Designed to help identify elements important in forming social media policy. Research methodology applied to a comparative case study of the deinstitutionalisation of children in bulgaria and ukraine chrissie gale. Comparative social policy and social transfer this case study forms one of six submitted to swap to illustrate ways in which academics use social policy. Comparative social policy research papers academia.
Pdf theories and methods in comparative social policy semantic. This paper, together with others in this series, attempts to fill this gap by taking a distinctive approach to social policy, which it sees as. Please select the fulltext pdf link on the left to view the complete article. University of tampere, mykolas romeris university and johannes kepler university linz. Meaning and scope over the decades and at various times ghanaian social institutions have come under different influences resulting in changes of some kind some of these changes came about through internal factors such as civil wars, natural disasters, population growth and pressure on available resources etc. Comparative social policy explores the new context of social policy and considers how crossnational theory and research can respond to the challenges facing welfare.
The current context of social policy is one in which many of the old certainties of the past have been eroded. The online content platform for edward elgar publishing. Use your bodleian password to connect to the bodleian libraries wifi or ethernet, and to log into library pcs. Most types of social policy analysis could be regarded as comparative in. N research design, using quantitative or qualitative comparative analyses of welfare state regimes as an example. This has uses in many fields, such as medicine, business, and social sciences. Policy transfer and the internationalisation of social policy. Understand the advantages and disadvantages of a comparative approach to the study of key pillars of social policy, such as education, employment, social security, housing and. The formal course title, as you certainly know, is social legislation and social policy. For some, social policy is often a leading obstacle to the pursuit of inclusive and sustainable development, through unintended. Computerassisted text analysis for comparative politics christopher lucas department of government and institute for quantitative social science, harvard university, 1737 cambridge st.
If you are focusing on a comparative analysis for your project you should opt for this template. In particular, there is virtually no comparative research on social policy issues or on how social policies affect economic development. The authors use examples from a wide range of social policy analysis to illustrate what can be gained by conducting comparative social policy research. Journal of international and comparative social policy, 312, 151. The essay further delineates comparative analysis by an extensive discussion of the selected articles. You are not authenticated to view the full text of this chapter or article. Session overview society and its institutions are dynamic thus social change is of interest to sociologists. Comparative social policy research methods course code.
Defining comparative social policy in a handbook of comparative social policy second edition. Aims through independently conducted and supervised research, this course aims to develop students. This extensively revised edition of a handbook of comparative social policy provides uptodate and valuable insights on key concepts and issues, such as globalization, crime, diversity, housing, child poverty, gender inequality, and social policy regime. Journal of international and comparative social policy skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Comparative social policy and welfare is part of the area of social sciences. Each institution is represented by a particular social group. The ambition of comparative public policy is toward better methodological and theoretical approaches for stronger descriptions and explanations of public policy development across space, time, or. College of education school of continuing and distance education 20142015 20162017 soci 222 comparative social institutions session social change and social institutions.
264 95 1489 939 204 319 1154 224 1328 630 994 1232 1231 258 1462 399 224 372 521 421 1063 1146 1085 343 1098 1155 1399 1202 727 188 1303 947 244 223 93 526 1347 669 368 275 1326 123 998